Data Point of the Week is AR Insider’s dive into the latest spatial computing figures. It includes data points, along with narrative insights and takeaways. For an indexed collection of data and reports, subscribe to ARtillery Pro.
In the ongoing debate over whether or not Pokemon Go is AR (or if it really matters), one argument is that most players turn off AR mode. It can deplete your battery and make gameplay harder. AR’s novelty in the game can also wear off after the first few times using it.
For those unfamiliar, AR Mode in Pokemon Go activates the user’s camera so that encountered Pokemon appear overlaid on real-world scenes. When AR Mode is off, the camera is likewise off so the backdrop within gameplay is animated, and can vary based on situational factors.
Niantic is open about AR mode’s limited use, and admits that AR isn’t a silver bullet for any game. CTO Phil Keslin said once that most people use AR only occasionally for posed photos of Pokemon in the real world. CEO John Hanke likewise said at GDC that AR mode is limiting.
“AR in and of itself is not a magic bullet for a hit game. There are some real drawbacks to it,” Hanke said on stage, adding that ideal interaction time for AR mode is two-to-three minutes. In fact, he admits that the majority of the gameplay should and does take place outside of AR.
The 2-3 minute sweet spot makes sense given physical realities. AR is a snack (VR is a meal) as we’ve examined. Not only is there arm strain, but cultural factors preclude holding up a camera while walking around. And focus can be distracted in awkward ways in high-traffic areas.
After learning some of these lessons, Niantic recently formalized the feature Keslin referenced, to let players pose with their Pokemon in real-world scenes. Known as Go Snapshot, it optimizes AR’s role within the app by giving it an official feature that plays to the technology’s strengths.
In other words GO Snapshot could do AR a favor by letting it be its best self within the game (versus AR mode), as validated by user behavior. And it could spread AR outside the game through people sharing AR photos, a la Snapchat Lenses. We’ll see creative uses of the feature.
Speaking of doing AR a favor, findings like the 2-3 minute sweet spot are gold for anyone developing AR. As a byproduct of its games (and Real World Platform), Niantic is testing the waters for user behavior. And it has a pretty large and reliable sample of 65 million active users.
As Real World Platform continues to develop, and as Harry Potter Wizards Unite rolls out, we’ll see more UX lessons. And we’ll be paying close attention whenever those nuggets are disclosed. Mobile AR interactions are still a developing art, and it will be a long learning process.
Disclosure: AR Insider has no financial stake in the companies mentioned in this post, nor received payment for its production. Disclosure and ethics policy can be seen here.
Header Image Credit: Niantic