AR Insider Case Studies examine learnings from industrial AR deployments. This post extracts a case study from ARtillery Intelligence’s recent report, Industrial AR: Benefits & Barriers. See more or subscribe here.
Industrial AR’s early days are all about proving the technology’s efficacy and ROI. Scope AR is one player that’s taken this to heart, publishing data for AR proof points like increased manufacturing output, better accuracy in maintenance, and reducing time for task completion.
For example, Scope AR’s Work Link software for pre-authored AR instructions reduced Lockheed Martin’s “orient & decide” portion of satellite assembly by 99 percent. This type of work is where AR shines, as it reduces the cognitive load that’s inherent in translating 2D manuals to 3D space.
“To put into common terms, think about IKEA furniture,” said Scope AR CEO Scott Montgomerie at AWE Europe. “You have to look at those paper instructions, read weird diagrams, and do mental mapping. Multiply the complexity of that by a thousand and that’s the challenge we’re facing.”
Beyond pre-authored instructions, remote assistance (a.k.a “see what I see”) is proving valuable. Fast-food equipment supplier Prince Castle used Scope AR’s Remote AR to fix on-site equipment. It achieved a 100 percent first-time diagnosis rate and a 50 percent labor cost reduction.
“There’s about thirty things that can go wrong with these pieces of equipment,” said Montgomerie. “Figuring out which one of those things have gone wrong is really the key, and just with a phone call, their diagnosis rate was terrible — about 90 percent failure in first-time diagnosis.”
AR can also have macro-effects in an organization, such as reducing the negative impact of subject-matter experts retiring. Shifting them from field work to remote assistance can delay retirement. It can also let diminishing volumes of experts cover more ground through telepresence.
“In the next five years, they’re going to lose 330 years’ worth of experience just by having baby boomers retiring,” said Montgomerie. “These guys have spent 35 years learning exactly how to maintain, fix and operate equipment, and that knowledge is literally walking out the door.”
Unilever realized this advantage, as well as the unit economics of lessened downtime. Using Remote AR, it was able to reduce downtime by 50 percent for an ROI of 1,717 percent. The benefit is having things fixed faster when you don’t have to wait for a human to travel to the site.
The Hard Part
But ROI proof points only get you so far. It’s also about setting the technology up to succeed and avoiding “pilot purgatory” by appealing to stakeholders throughout an organization — business leaders, IT departments and employees. And that’s more about marketing than technology.
Business leaders are the easy part and are usually sold on AR’s performance gains and ROI proposition. Then comes IT, whose job is to be risk-averse. Montgomerie’s advice: Get them involved as soon as possible. That may seem counterintuitive, but it pays dividends downstream.
“I think it’s a common mistake — one we’ve certainly made — to do an end-run around I.T.,” said Montgomerie. “It’s easy to say ‘yeah, let’s prove the value first and then we’ll worry about I.T. when we get to scale. IT will [block] you at that point, so you need to get them in the conversation early.”
He also recommends deploying AR through smartphones and tablets when possible. The I.T. and data security pushback is lower with mobile devices, given their tenure and trustworthiness in the enterprise. Headsets like the HoloLens conversely haven’t always gained that level of I.T. trust.
As for employees, it’s likewise hard to win them over. But successful deployment requires their buy-in. Resistance includes fear of new technology and job security. Montgomerie recommends educating them on how it benefits them, rather than repeating the same ROI talking points.
“We’re talking about some pretty impressive ROI numbers here,” he said. “If I’m a worker I’m thinking, ‘oh well, the company can still do exactly the same on their bottom line with 50 percent of the workforce… does that mean I have a one in two chance of keeping my job next year’.”
In a broader sense, Montgomerie recommends deploying AR where it works best. It doesn’t work in rote and automated functions, where employees are already fine-tuned. It shines in low-volume, high complexity situations (like space shuttles), or high volume, small improvement scenarios.
Put another way, don’t be a hammer searching for nails. Act in a needs-driven way to deploy AR in targeted and optimized ways. Scope AR took this path with aerospace, engineering and heavy equipment, but Montgomerie believes there are many other verticals primed for AR.
“I think there’s an impression that AR is great for everything. I can tell you it’s not,” he said. “We’ve chosen key industries to go after… there are other industries where this is a greenfield — things like medical, construction, and logistics. There are some great use cases there.”
Check out the full report here.